Scroll for more

Why Math Workshop?

InSync-PEBC_Heads_Wendy-213s web

Wendy Ward Hoffer, MA

Copying math is not learning
Every once in a while, I dream back to my high school calculus courses. I can still hear the rattling sound of our teacher energetically chalking symbols on the slate at the front of the room. He would spend the majority of fifty minutes at the board working conic sections and integrals with aplomb. We copied down everything he wrote. Once in a while, he would holler at someone to tell him what to do next. I always sat in the same seat, second row, third back, where I sometimes ducked behind the big boys who liked to sit up front and be called on, but I would get hollered at anyhow, and would have to cough up a derivative or a domain, either to be scolded or praised—I was often unsure which to expect. We learned math by copying.

When the AP exam presented us with big blank sheets of paper on which to scrawl solutions all our own, I remember desperately wishing I understood more about what all the symbols represented and which I was meant to put where. Despite my long years as a devoted mathematical spectator, I had yet to grasp the underlying point. During the exam, I wrestled to combat an existential crisis: Why were we doing this?

What does understanding look like?
The purpose of teaching and learning mathematics is understanding. When we understand, we can remember, transfer knowledge to new contexts, apply concepts to novel situations, look at problems from varied perspectives, and explain in ways that make sense to others. Though this was not my initial experience as a calculus learner, that course did propel me to recognize the importance of understanding, the need that I—and all students—have to develop strategies that will help us to make meaning of mathematics for ourselves.

To that end, a math workshop is an ideal forum for learners to construct their own mathematical understanding through rich interactions with both content and peers, in line with Lev Vygotsky’s theory of social constructivism (1978). The big idea behind a math workshop is that whoever is doing the majority of the speaking, solving, justifying, and explaining is doing the learning; since our purpose is to teach students math, our workshops need to be about students doing the work of mathematicians. In a workshop, learners are actors, not audience members, and teachers are coaches, not sages. A math workshop is a structure that turns over the work of learning math—and the responsibility for doing so—to students.

STEM Hoffer-3170Learners thrive when they experience instead of observe math
A classic workshop, lasting the length of one period of math, offers discrete opportunities in every lesson or learning sequence for direct instruction or modeling (mini-lesson), the majority of time devoted to students’ independent and small group work on rich tasks (work time), and a final segment for synthesis, metacognition, and formative assessment (reflection). Recent research on math reform demonstrates such approaches to be especially powerful when applied in heterogeneous groups (Boaler 2014). Though the workshop structure is flexible, the ritual of the workshop is a powerful way to consistently convey to students that their work and their thinking are the primary focus of learning time.

Learners thrive in a math workshop when they are apprenticed as capable, independent problem solvers. Workshop model instruction affords learners the time to experience, not just to observe, all eight Mathematical Practices detailed by the Common Core: In order to, first, “Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them,” students need opportunities to face challenges and experience the productive struggle called for by NCTM’s Mathematical Teaching Practices. Workshop is the cauldron of mathematical grappling: We set learners up with challenges, support their progress, and together look back on all they achieved and came to understand.

Math Workshop

Workshop model allows time for generative conversations that deepen learning.

Discourse solidifies understanding
Learners can tackle more challenging problems collaboratively than they could independently; their comprehension is catalyzed by hearing the thinking of their peers. For this reason, discourse—engaged, accountable conversations about mathematical content—plays a key role in a math workshop. Discourse affords learners with opportunities to reason, argue, and critique the thinking of others. Students need training and skilled facilitation to develop their capacity for generative conversations, and we know from international comparative studies of classroom practice that discussing and defending mathematical ideas promotes students’ mathematical understanding.



Excerpt from
Hoffer, Wendy Ward. Developing Literate Mathematicians: A Guide for Integrating Language and Literacy Instruction into Secondary Mathematics. Reston: The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, Inc., 2016. (15-16)

Vygotsky, L. “Interaction between Learning and Development.” In Mind and Society, translated by M. Cole, pp 79-91. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1978

Boaler, Jo, and David Foster. “Raising Expectations and Achievement: The Impact of Wide Scale Mathematics Reform Giving All Students Access to High Quality Mathematics.” 2014.

Learn More at an Upcoming Institute


Enjoy Denver, the Mile High City, when you attend the Minds on Math institute

Minds on Math Institute
In this institute, you will learn how to address all eight of the common core standards for mathematical practice within workshop model instruction. We offer this institute twice a year, we hope you can join us at one!

November 14-15, 2017
March 6-7, 2018
Aurora, CO

Explore how explicit thinking strategy instruction can promote sutdents mathematical understanding while preparing them with problem-solving skills they can apply on standardized assessments and real world situations that require them to think as mathematicians.
Learn More

See Wendy Ward Hoffer in person at a PEBC event

No Comments

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Show Buttons
Hide Buttons